Philanthropedia Blog

Identifying High-Impact Animal Welfare, Rights & Protection Nonprofits in the U.S.

June 6th, 2011 by dawn Leave a reply »



Animal welfare, rights, and protection is one of the most popular issue areas to which individual donors give and is an area in which colleagues working in the field are extremely passionate.
So, we are excited to help donors identify high-impact nonprofits in this issue area!

I interviewed fourteen influential experts in the field to better understand the scope of this issue area (thank you to those of you who shared your expertise with me to shape the scope of this research)! Many experts spoke of the importance of protecting animals similar to protecting the marginalized in society. Without human support, many animals face abuse, neglect, and suffering. Although the majority of nonprofits in this field work with companion animals (dogs, cats, horses), many experts I spoke with talked about the importance of including farm animals, animals used for research, and wildlife animals in the scope of this research. As a result, we are asking experts to identify high-impact nonprofits that work in one or more of the following categories, protecting:

  1. Companion animals
  2. Farm animals
  3. Animals used for research
  4. Wildlife animals

Types of nonprofits might include advocacy, legislative, education, regulatory, or direct services (shelters, animal rescue, and sanctuaries).

Nonprofits excluded from this research include for-profit organizations and funders.

In the survey, we ask experts to recommend up to three national nonprofits and three local nonprofits working in the area of animal welfare, rights and protection. For local nonprofits, we will primarily focus on the California, New York, Florida, Texas, and Pennsylvania, because these states have the largest concentration of nonprofits working in animal protection.

If you are an expert in animal welfare, rights and protection, you should have received an email from us with a link to our survey and we hope you will share your perspective and insights with us! If for some reason we have missed you and you think you have a valuable perspective to offer, please contact me, Dawn at dkwan@guidestar.org, and we would love to include your insights.

Additionally, I’m sure I haven’t been able to capture every nuance in this sector, so I invite your feedback and thoughts about how you might think about this work. For those readers less familiar with this topic, I hope you will learn something new and tune in again when we have the results of this research. Thank you all for your participation!

The findings below were a result of interviewing fourteen influential experts in the field.

 

————————————————————————————————————————————————————————————————————————————————————————————————————————————————————————————————————————

Companion Animals

Most nonprofits that work with animals work with companion animals, which mainly refer to dogs, cats, and horses. Out of the 12,500 agencies that work with animals in the U.S., 12,000 work with companion animals. Furthermore, approximately 70 percent of funding to animals goes to supporting companion animals.

 

Most of these nonprofit’s efforts focus on shelters because approximately five percent of pet animals pass through shelters in the U.S (6-8 million animals). However, many animals die or suffer in shelters (even good shelters with high adoption rates) because they don’t have good services to protect the animals. Poor sheltering includes starvation, lack of care, being attacked or killed by another animal, or being subjected to infectious diseases. Poor shelter care is a difficult issue to talk to the public about because the media doesn’t want to slander shelters. The key is to help shelters help themselves.

 

Efforts to protect companion animals in shelters include:

 

  • Providing general assistance to shelters- General assistance includes equipment, capital projects and adoption programs.
  • Decreasing euthanasia of animals- Many animals that have no diseases or very minor diseases are euthanized. This problem is sometimes coined the “disease of euthanasia”.
  • Improving spay/neuter initiatives- Spay/neuter initiatives help decrease the number of animals that end up in shelters and also protects the health of animals because it lowers disease rates such as prostate cancer. Making spay/neuter initiatives low or no cost for low-income pet owners is seen as an important plan to reducing the number of animals. It is also extremely important to spay and neuter cats because cats are “reproductive machines” and can give birth as early as four months old!
  • Transporting adoptable animals- Animals are transported from areas with low adoption rates (e.g. the South) to areas of high adoption demand (for example California and metropolitan areas) to help balance out supply and demand for pets.
  • Encouraging people to put identification on their pets- so they are able to locate them when they lose their pets. An example of this is micro-chipping.
  • Improving shelter medicine- Most veterinary students are trained to look after individual animals but not hundreds of animals in one space because of the private profession. Students have been trained to care for farm animals and horses in herds, but not dogs and cats in herds.

 

Other efforts surrounding protecting companion animals include:

 

  • Illegalizing organized acts of cruelty- This includes dog and cock fighting.
  • Stopping individual acts of cruelty that people have against pets- This includes puppy mills and mass killings in shelters. Animal forensics helps organizations respond to cruelty cases and prosecute those who have conducted the cruelty.
  • Improving animal control- Most animals that end up in private shelters pass through animal control. However, a lot of times, the animals are exposed to diseases and severe stress at animal control, so this increases the cost for shelters. Animal control centers affect 20,000-75,000 animals per year. If one can make a change in the conditions of animal control, it would  make a huge impact.
  • Rescuing animals during times of disaster- an example is the large scale animal rescue operation that happened after hurricane Katrina.
  • Conducting research- to understand why people give up their animals and how to prevent this from happening to decrease numbers at shelters.
  • Providing general assistance to horse owners- Horses are very expensive to maintain and keep. Assistance comes in the form of emergency hay, capital improvements, and humane education grants for equine groups.

 

Farm Animals

We decided to include farm animals in our research because factory farming affects the largest number of animals in the sector. Ten billion animals are raised for food production in the U.S. every year, and 60 billion animals are raised for this purpose worldwide. There are no federal policies or laws to protect animals that are made for food because they are exempt from the federal wildlife animal act and anti-cruelty act. Some of the issues farm animals face include:

  • Confinement- One of the worst problems is the extreme confinement of animals where animals can’t even move one inch in during their entire life during the production and transportation process.
  • Killing of unwanted animals- Unwanted chicken are sometimes ground up alive or left in a dumpster to die. There was a recent exposé of a Texas farm where unwanted calves were being hit in the head with hammers.
  • Antibiotics- Antibiotics are used to make animals grow faster, sometimes at a very unnatural rate where the animal’s internal organs can’t keep up with their external growth.
  • Slaughter process

 

Animal Experimentation

We decided to include animal experimentation because it plays an important role in animal welfare, rights, and protection. In particular the use of animals for the purposes of biomedical research, product testing, and educational demonstrations. We are interested in nonprofits that work on preventing the use of primates, and especially, chimpanzees; cosmetic and household product testing; dissection and other harmful use of animals in educational settings (K through professional training); and sale of former pets by shelters (“pound seizure”) and “Class B” dealers to research.  Types of animals that are used for research purposes include mice, rats, guinea pigs, fish, frogs, birds, dogs, cats, monkeys, and other animals.

 

Wildlife

 

Although wildlife is usually bundled under the category of the environment, we felt that our research wouldn’t be comprehensive if we didn’t include the conservation and protection of wildlife. One area of concern is the U.S. Department of Agriculture’s Wildlife Service’s predator control program. In 2009 alone, Wildlife Services killed more than 4 million animals in the U.S., including 115,000 mammalian carnivores; close to 90,000 were coyotes. Each year, roughly $120 million is spent on this program. Another issue in this category is coyote and fox penning. This involves sending packs of domestic dogs into a fenced-off enclosure to chase to exhaustion and often tear apart a captive coyote or fox. Other issues related to wildlife protection include:

 

  • · Conservation and habitat
  • · Fur farming
  • · Exotic pets
  • · Trafficking and smuggling of wildlife
  • · Treatment of captive animals
  • · Preservation of endangered species
  • · Preservation of wildlife in national parks
  • · Land protection

 

These are just a summary of my notes after having talked to fourteen experts in the field. What do you think? What have I missed? What might you add? Please feel free to leave a comment and help build on these notes.

40 comments

  1. I will be responding to the survey, and the information provided here is supberb. But the construct of the assessment with respect to organizations in the companion animal subsector (three national, three local organizations) misses fundamental characteristics of the sector that donors should understand, one of which is somewhat referenced — the emphasis on sheltering — but not sufficiently explored.

    The locus of companion animal welfare is intensively local because almost every initiative bearing on the welfare of companion animals is and has to be local: licensing; regulations governing desease prevention and management, human interaction, and commercial activity; sheltering and adoption.

    That companion animal welfare — specifically that of dogs and cats — is so local explains why two-thirds to three-quarters of local animal welfare 501(c)(3)s are contracted with and substantially funded by their contacts with government for animal control services, a fact critically important to understanding their business models and financials. A proper assessment of local animal welfare organizations would divide them into two classes depending on wherther or not they have animal control comntracts.

    There is no national SPCA or Humane Society with which community SPCAs or humane societies are affiliated. The most active national fundraising organizations either exploit their names in nationwide fundraising — New York City’s American SPCA and the Washington, D.C.- based Humane Society of the US are the most egregious examples — or unabashedly raise money nationally for their local operations, such as North Shore Animal League (Long Island) and Animal Rescue Foundation (Walnut Creek, CA).

    While incidents — stories about — animal cruelty dominate humane organization fundraising, the principal cause of dog and cat homelessness and, therefore,need for sheltering and, ultimately, unnecessary euthanasia is over-population. It is only solved locally by a combination of regulation and licensing (of breeding and neuttering). Ironically, high incidence of translocating animals for adoption is incidence of animals being moved from under-regulated communities to well-reglated communities.

  2. Karel Minor says:

    I just responded and agree in large part with Christopher. A dispropotionate amount of stafffing, funding and effort in animal welfare goes to local animal sheltering, animal control, adoption, euthanasia, etc. While large organizations like HSUS and ASPCA get notice for their large budgets, they pale in comparison to the combined budgets on local shelters. Pennsylvania’s spending alone on these things dwarfs the seemingly large $100,000,000 budget of HSUS. Multiplied fifty-fold the half national/half local focus does seem a bit out of proportion.

    Since no opinion in animal welfare can ever go unchallenged, I will question the over emphasis on “over population” as the problem facing animals in shelters. Since increasingly numbers of communities face rising populations of young adult and older animals being surrendered or straying and ultimately dying in shelters, it would seem that quantity alone is no longer the case. Behavior, health, lifestyle, lack of resource and a wide variety of other issues seem to be competing causes for animals ending up in shelters now, not merely too many puppies and kitties in the world.

    Bravo to Guidestar for taking note of our little billion dollar charitable industry and thanks for asking us to share our opinions!

  3. Karel Minor says:

    I just responded and agree in large part with Christopher. A dispropotionate amount of stafffing, funding and effort in animal welfare goes to local animal sheltering, animal control, adoption, euthanasia, etc. While large organizations like HSUS and ASPCA get notice for their large budgets, they pale in comparison to the combined budgets on local shelters. Pennsylvania’s spending alone on these things matches or dwarfs the seemingly large $100,000,000 budget of HSUS. Multiplied fifty-fold the half national/half local focus does seem a bit out of proportion.

    Since no opinion in animal welfare can ever go unchallenged, I will question the over emphasis on “over population” as the problem facing animals in shelters. Since increasingly numbers of communities face rising populations of young adult and older animals being surrendered or straying and ultimately dying in shelters, it would seem that quantity alone is no longer the case. Behavior, health, lifestyle, lack of resource and a wide variety of other issues seem to be competing causes for animals ending up in shelters now, not merely too many puppies and kitties in the world.

    Bravo to Guidestar for taking note of our little billion dollar charitable industry and thanks for asking us to share our opinions!

  4. dawn says:

    Thank you for offering your great perspective Chris and Karel about the importance of local animal nonprofits, in particular animal shelters, in this field.

    For our other causes (with the exception of our 2010 Bay Area causes), we conduct research to identify nonprofits that work on a national level. However, after talking to experts, we realized how important local nonprofits play in the field of animal welfare, rights, and protection, hence we changed the format of our survey to reflect that. Instead of asking experts to recommend four national nonprofits and two start-up nonprofits, we ask experts in the animal protection space to recommend three national nonprofits and three local nonprofits.

    In response to Karel’s question, the reason why we divided it as a half national and half local focus primarily has to do with our research methodology. We cannot ask too many questions from our experts, because they are extremely busy, and we really appreciate them taking the time to share their expertise with us already. However we also need sufficient number of recommendations to come up with a list of top nonprofits.

    For this cause, the reason why we ask experts to recommend national nonprofits is because we believe they play an important role, in particular in the legislative, advocacy and other federal policy levels. However, as Chris mentions, local nonprofits, are usually the ones who provide the services, hence we felt it was necessary to highlight the great work that they do.

    I hope this clarifies our approach to our research for animal welfare, rights, and protection, and look forward to getting more comments and feedback about this field and how we can improve!

  5. I would like to go to the BJ auction!

  6. I enjoy reading an article that will make men and women think. Also, many thanks for allowing me to comment!

  7. Outstanding merchandise from you, dude. I’ve got realize your things prior to and you’re going to be just very great. I genuinely like what you have acquired here, absolutely like what you’re going to be stating as well as the way by which you say it. You make it entertaining and you also however proper care for to keep it sensible. I cant wait around to read a lot more from you. It is definitely a terrific web site.

  8. religion says:

    Hey, you used to be able to write amazing, but the previous various posts happen to be kinda boring… I miss your tremendous writings. Previous many posts are just just a little out of monitor! can come on!

  9. Glinda says:

    Do you have a spam issue on this blog; I also am a blogger, and I was wanting to
    know your situation; many of us have developed some nice
    procedures and we are looking to swap techniques with other folks, please shoot me an e-mail if
    interested.

  10. Ha ha, lucky, let I met such a good article, content is also very good, if the circumstances are also so thrilling, really exciting article oh. Continue to pay attention to this article, I think life is a must.

  11. Brilliant merchandise from you, person. I’ve realize your stuff previous to and you happen to be just far too exceptional. I really like what you might have acquired right here, surely like what you might be stating along with the way wherein you say it. You make it pleasant and you however deal with to maintain it sensible. I can not wait around to examine much much more from you. This really is truly a fantastic site.

  12. I used to be just looking for this details for a though. Right after half-dozen several hours of continuous Googleing, at previous I got it in your own web site. I wonder what the heck is the lack of Bing approach that never rank this form of informative internet sites in high with the listing. Commonly the best world-wide-web web-sites are total of garbage.

  13. So Huggett says:

    Wanted to put up you a really smaller phrase so as to thank you all over again aided by the exceptional principles you have discussed at this time. It is so unbelievably generous of you to provide with no restraint what a few people would’ve supplied as an e e book to create some income on their very own, notably thinking of the fact that you might have tried it inside the function you wanted. These issues also acted like a fantastic technique to realize that many people possess the identical motivation considerably like my really own personal to know somewhat extra regarding this condition. I’m specific you will discover a great deal much more satisfying opportunities within the future for individuals who choose a examine your site.

  14. Write more, thats all I have to say. Literally, it seems as though you relied on the video to make your point.
    You clearly know what youre talking about, why waste
    your intelligence on just posting videos to your blog when you could be giving us something
    enlightening to read?

  15. world view says:

    I will right away seize your rss feed as I can not find your e-mail subscription link or e-newsletter service. Do you have any? Please let me recognise so that I may just subscribe. Thanks.

  16. Domestic use of Power cables: The simplest example of power cable could be a microphone or a headphone.
    Others have rough handles that can make it harder for you to keep your grip over
    your power tools. Those electric wirings have been the major
    source of income for such industries as the overseas corporate houses have given positive response to the service of these providers of cabling equipments.

    My blog :: plumbing supply spring tx

  17. Howdy! I know this is kind of off topic but I was wondering which blog platform are you using for
    this website? I’m getting tired of WordPress because I’ve had problems with hackers and I’m looking at options for
    another platform. I would be awesome if you could point me in the direction of a good platform.

    Feel free to surf to my blog; A2Z Health Massage School

  18. Art says:

    Today, I went to the beachfront with my children. I found a
    sea shell and gave it to my 4 year old daughter and said “You can hear the ocean if you put this to your ear.” She put the shell to her ear and screamed.
    There was a hermit crab inside and it pinched her ear.
    She never wants to go back! LoL I know this is entirely off topic
    but I had to tell someone!

    My web blog – Cheap Massage Therapy, Art,

  19. Everyone loves what you guys are usually up too.
    This kind of clever work and reporting! Keep up the good
    works guys I’ve included you guys to blogroll.

    Here is my webpage: A2Z Health Massage School

  20. Terrific post but I was wanting to know if you could write a litte more on this subject? I’d be very grateful if you could elaborate a little bit more. Appreciate it!

  21. Rodent Guys says:

    Trapping is the most effective but it may not be for you so bbe
    sure and do your research. Wheeler’s Pest Control are a family operated and run pest control service,
    which deal with any type of pest emergency. This geberal
    classification is that the Rodentia are more commonly known ass Rodents.

  22. I was pretty pleased to discover this website. I need to to thank you for your time due to
    this wonderful read!! I definitely appreciated every part of it and i also have
    you bookmarked to see new information in your blog.

  23. This is a great tip especially to those fresh to the blogosphere.
    Short but very precise info… Many thanks for sharing this one.
    A must read article!

  24. Hello my friend! I want to say that this post is amazing, great written and come with almost all vital infos.

    I’d like to look more posts like this .

  25. You can certainly see your enthusiasm in the work you write.
    The world hopes for even more passionate writers like you who are not
    afraid to mention how they believe. All the time follow your
    heart.

  26. Scott says:

    An outstanding share! I’ve just forwarded this onto a coworker who had been conducting a little
    homework on this. And he in fact ordered me lunch due to the fact that I discovered it for
    him… lol. So allow me to reword this…. Thank YOU for the meal!!
    But yeah, thanks for spending the time to discuss this matter here on your web site.

  27. Your style is unique in comparison to other folks I’ve read stuff from.
    Thanks for posting when you have the opportunity,
    Guess I will just book mark this page.

  28. If you are going for finest contents like I do, just visit this web site all the time as it gives feature
    contents, thanks

  29. Age: grow older, they premature ejaculation are able to manage his ejaculation has to start for at least once in a relationship
    rapid ejaculation, then wait ten seconds and then release it
    for around 10 minutes. She deserves to be a man ejaculates prematurely later in his life leaves him.
    You will find that reaching orgasm. Learn more here This
    mimics premature ejaculation the warm, moist area of
    your sexual stamina.

  30. Marcus says:

    Nice post. I learn something totally new and challenging on sites I stumbleupon everyday.
    It’s always interesting to read through content from other authors and use something
    from their websites.

Leave a Reply


Philanthropedia is a registered 501(c)3 organization. All of your donations are 100% tax-deductible.